Apex Roofing & Construction Text a photoCall 682-558-1382
Homeowner guide

Class 4 Impact-Resistant Shingles in Texas: What They Are and Whether They Pay Off

Updated Oct 7, 2026 by Apex Roofing & Construction. General information for North Texas homeowners, not legal or insurance advice.

Short answerA Class 4 shingle passed the toughest level of the UL 2218 lab test, which drops 2-inch steel balls on the same spot twice. It resists hail better than many standard shingles but is not hail-proof. In Texas, any insurance discount for an impact-resistant roof is set by each insurance company, so ask before you buy, and under Property Code 202.011 most HOAs cannot ban them if they look like the shingles already allowed.

If you have replaced a roof after hail, you have probably heard someone pitch "Class 4" shingles. Some people say they pay for themselves. Others call them a gimmick. The real answer depends on your insurer, your HOA and how long you plan to stay in the house.

What does Class 4 mean?

Class 4 is the top rating in a lab test called UL 2218. A similar test, FM 4473, uses the same four classes. IBHS explains that these tests rate roof coverings from Class 1 to Class 4 using steel or ice balls from 1.25 to 2 inches across.

RatingTest ball diameter
Class 11.25 inches
Class 21.50 inches
Class 31.75 inches
Class 42.00 inches

In UL 2218, the steel ball is dropped from the height needed to match the energy of a real hailstone that size. Each spot is hit twice. IBHS describes the pass rule: any tearing, fracturing, cracking or rupturing on the back of the shingle is a failure. Dents, crushed granules or marks only on the top surface are not counted as failures.

Are Class 4 shingles hail-proof?

No. IBHS research makes three points:

  1. Steel balls are not hail. IBHS says the standard tests do not exactly replicate natural hailstone impacts. So IBHS built its own test using lab-made hailstones.
  2. Not all Class 4 products perform the same. In IBHS's own hail testing, every impact-resistant shingle rated Good or Excellent against 2-inch hail was made with polymer-modified asphalt. Some older designs that used a reinforcing backing did worse than the same maker's standard shingle.
  3. The difference is modest. Against 1.5-inch lab hail, IBHS found that new impact-resistant and standard shingles both performed well, with impact-resistant products scoring about 16% better overall. Against 2-inch hail, where a maker's impact-resistant shingle beat its standard one, the impact-resistant shingles rated Good or Excellent averaged about 14% higher scores, and up to 34% for some products.

IBHS publishes product ratings (Excellent, Good, Marginal, Poor). Its 2021 scorecard reported eight products rated Good or Excellent. Ask your roofer which IBHS rating the product you are quoted has earned, if any.

Will Class 4 shingles lower my insurance in Texas?

Maybe. It depends entirely on your insurance company.

The Texas Department of Insurance says impact-resistant roofing may be eligible for discounts, and that the discount amount is set by each insurance company on a company-by-company basis. TDI does not list a required amount. Each insurer decides:

  • how big the credit is, if it offers one,
  • which test results it accepts,
  • how the product must be labeled, and
  • what paperwork you must provide.

TDI also says a Class 4 roof covering would receive the highest credit of the four classes. For Texas Windstorm Insurance Association (TWIA) policies on the coast, the contractor fills out TDI form PC068 after installation. Other insurers may use that form or their own.

Before you buy, call your agent and ask:

  1. Do you give a credit for a UL 2218 Class 4 roof?
  2. How much would it save on my policy each year?
  3. What proof do you need: invoice, product name, wrapper label, a form?
  4. Does the credit change my wind and hail deductible or coverage in any way?

Then do the math. Divide the extra cost of the Class 4 roof by the yearly savings to see how many years it takes to pay back.

Can my HOA say no to impact-resistant shingles?

Generally, no. Texas Property Code Section 202.011 says a property owners' association may not prohibit shingles designed primarily to be wind and hail resistant, to give better heating and cooling efficiency, or to generate solar power.

The HOA can still require that the shingles:

  1. resemble the shingles used or allowed in the subdivision,
  2. are more durable than, and of equal or better quality than, those shingles, and
  3. match the look of the homes around yours.

Your HOA may still require architectural approval. Check your deed restrictions and submit before work starts, with the product name and color.

How much more do Class 4 shingles cost?

Less than you might expect, at least for the shingles themselves. In a cost survey across seven U.S. markets, IBHS found impact-resistant shingles rated Good or Excellent cost about 9% more per square on average. In the Dallas-Fort Worth market, the difference was only about 4%. That survey dates from 2020 and covers material only. Labor, tear-off and other parts of the job usually cost the same. Ask for bids that price both options side by side. See what a new roof costs.

What are the pros and cons?

ProsCons
Better hail resistance in IBHS testing, especially polymer-modified productsNot hail-proof; large or wind-driven hail can still cause damage
Possible insurance credit, if your insurer offers oneEach insurer sets its own credit, and it may be small
HOAs generally cannot ban them under Property Code 202.011HOA can still set look and quality conditions
Small material premium in DFW in IBHS's 2020 surveyStill costs more up front
May mean fewer repairs after moderate hailDents may count as "cosmetic" under some policies (see below)

What is a cosmetic damage exclusion, and why does it matter here?

Some Texas home policies carry an endorsement that excludes cosmetic hail damage to roof coverings. TDI approved these endorsements in 1998. Cosmetic damage means damage that alters the physical appearance of the roof covering but does not let water in or stop the roof from doing its job.

This matters for impact-resistant roofs. A metal or Class 4 roof may dent but still keep water out. If your policy has a cosmetic exclusion, those dents may not be paid. Read your policy, or ask your agent whether it has one.

Is a Class 4 roof worth it for my house?

It is most likely worth it when:

  • your insurer offers a meaningful credit,
  • you plan to stay in the house for years,
  • your area has a history of hail, and
  • the price difference in your bids is small.

It is less compelling if your insurer offers no credit and you plan to sell soon. Either way, a bad install can undo a good shingle. Ask for the manufacturer's installation instructions to be followed, and keep the product label, invoice and warranty for your records. TDI also suggests considering roofing materials less likely to be damaged by wind, hail or fire when you replace a roof.

Common questions

What does Class 4 mean on a shingle?

It is the highest rating in the UL 2218 impact test (and the similar FM 4473 test). Test panels are hit twice in the same spot by a 2-inch steel ball. The product passes if no crack or opening shows on the back.

Do Texas insurance companies have to give a discount for Class 4 shingles?

TDI says impact-resistant roofs may be eligible for discounts, and that the amount is set by each insurance company on a company-by-company basis. Each company also decides which test results and paperwork it accepts. TDI does not list a required discount, so ask your agent before you buy.

Can my HOA stop me from installing impact-resistant shingles?

Generally no. Texas Property Code 202.011 says an HOA cannot prohibit shingles designed to be wind and hail resistant. The HOA can require that they resemble the shingles allowed in the subdivision, are more durable and of equal or better quality, and match the look of nearby homes.

Are Class 4 shingles hail-proof?

No. Class 4 means the shingle passed a lab test with steel balls. IBHS notes the test does not exactly copy real hailstones, and the pass rule ignores dents and granule loss on the top surface. Very large or wind-driven hail can still damage them.

How much more do Class 4 shingles cost in DFW?

In a 2020 IBHS cost survey, impact-resistant shingles that earned IBHS Good or Excellent ratings cost on average about 4% more per square than standard shingles in the Dallas-Fort Worth market. That is material only and prices change, so compare current written bids.

Sources

  1. Texas Department of Insurance: Impact-resistant roofing credits (24 Feb 2023) (accessed Oct 7, 2026)
  2. Texas Property Code Section 202.011 (via Texas Public Law) (accessed Oct 7, 2026)
  3. IBHS: Relative impact resistance of asphalt shingles, summary of UL 2218 tests (Aug 2014, PDF) (accessed Oct 7, 2026)
  4. IBHS: Hail impact performance of asphalt shingles, at a glance (2020, PDF) (accessed Oct 7, 2026)
  5. IBHS: New hail shingle performance scorecard (16 Jun 2021) (accessed Oct 7, 2026)
  6. IBHS: Roof 101 (accessed Oct 7, 2026)
  7. Texas Department of Insurance: Commissioner's Bulletin B-0030-98, cosmetic damage exclusion endorsements (accessed Oct 7, 2026)
  8. Texas Department of Insurance: Insurance and your roof (updated 1 Apr 2026) (accessed Oct 7, 2026)

Have a leak, storm damage or a project in mind?

Free inspections and written estimates, with photos of what we find.