Impact-Resistant and Class 4 Shingle Roofs in Fort Worth & Surrounding Areas
Hail is a fact of life in North Texas. Impact-resistant shingles take a harder hit before they crack. This page covers what the ratings mean and what they don't, and how to decide if they're worth it for your house.
What "impact-resistant" actually means
Impact ratings come from a lab test called UL 2218. Shingle samples are hit by steel balls dropped from a set height, twice in the same spot. The size of the ball sets the class. IBHS explains that the classes run from Class 1 to Class 4, using balls from 1.25 to 2 inches across.
| Rating | Steel ball size |
|---|---|
| Class 1 | 1.25 inches |
| Class 2 | 1.50 inches |
| Class 3 | 1.75 inches |
| Class 4 | 2.00 inches |
A shingle passes if the back shows no tearing, fracturing, cracking or rupturing after the hits. Dents and lost granules on the top surface don't count as a failure.
When people say "impact-resistant shingles," they usually mean Class 4. Some products carry a Class 3 rating instead. Both take a harder hit than a standard shingle. Class 4 is the higher bar.
What the rating doesn't promise
A Class 4 label does not mean hail-proof. IBHS points out that the standard tests use steel balls, which don't exactly copy real hailstones. In its own testing with lab-made hail, IBHS found that the impact-resistant shingles that did well against 2-inch hail were all made with polymer-modified asphalt. Not every product with the same label performs the same.
A good impact-resistant shingle can mean fewer repairs after the moderate hail North Texas sees most often. It won't stop a softball.
What went on a recent roof of ours
A recent Fort Worth roof of ours went on with Atlas Pinnacle Pristine architectural shingles in the color Oyster. Atlas lists that line with a Class 3 impact rating. That's impact-resistant, one step below Class 4. We mention it so you know exactly what that roof got.
We'll price the shingle lines you're interested in, including Class 4 products from major manufacturers. The final pick is yours.
Does it lower your insurance?
Maybe. It depends on your insurance company, not on us or the shingle maker.
The Texas Department of Insurance says impact-resistant roofs may be eligible for discounts, and that the amount is set by each company. Each insurer decides how big the credit is, which ratings qualify, and what proof it wants.
Before you choose, call your agent and ask:
- Do you give a credit for a Class 4 roof? For Class 3?
- How much would it save on my policy each year?
- What proof do you need: invoice, product name, wrapper label, a form?
- Does it change my wind and hail deductible?
Then compare. Divide the extra cost of the impact-resistant roof by the yearly savings to see how many years it takes to pay back.
One more thing to check: some Texas policies exclude cosmetic hail damage, meaning damage that changes how the roof looks but doesn't let water in. TDI approved those endorsements back in 1998. If yours has one, dents on a tough roof may not be covered. Read your policy or ask your agent.
Your HOA can't simply say no
If you live in an HOA, Texas Property Code section 202.011 helps you. It says an association may not prohibit shingles designed to be wind and hail resistant.
The HOA can still require that the shingles:
- resemble the shingles used or allowed in your subdivision;
- are more durable than, and equal or better in quality than, those shingles;
- match the look of the homes around yours.
Your HOA may still want an architectural request first. We can give you the product name, color and spec sheet for your submission.
What it costs
Impact-resistant shingles cost more than standard shingles. How much more depends on the product. In a 2020 cost survey, IBHS found the gap for impact-resistant shingles it rated Good or Excellent was about 4% per square in the Dallas-Fort Worth market. That figure is for material only, and prices change. Labor is usually the same either way.
The simple way to see the real difference is to get both options on one written estimate. We'll do that for you. Our roof cost guide explains the other things that drive the price.
The install matters as much as the shingle
An impact-rated shingle on a bad deck is still a bad roof. Every impact-resistant roof we install gets the same full process as any roof replacement:
- tear-off to the deck, with every board checked and bad ones replaced;
- new underlayment, drip edge, and ice and water protection in valleys;
- new flashing at walls, chimneys and pipes;
- ventilation checked and corrected;
- shingles installed to the manufacturer's instructions.
You get our 10-year workmanship warranty on the installation, plus the manufacturer's warranty on the shingles. Keep the invoice and product label in a safe place. Your insurer may ask for them if you apply for a credit.
Is it worth it for your house?
It's most likely worth it when your insurer offers a real credit, you plan to stay for years, and the price gap on your estimate is small. It's less compelling if there's no credit and you plan to sell soon.
For the full background, read our Class 4 shingles guide. Or call or text 682-558-1382 for a free roof inspection and a side-by-side estimate.
Common questions
What does Class 4 mean?
It's the top rating in the UL 2218 impact test. Shingle samples are hit twice in the same spot by a 2-inch steel ball. If no crack or split shows on the back, the product earns Class 4. Class 3 uses a 1.75-inch ball.
Will a Class 4 roof lower my insurance premium?
It might. The Texas Department of Insurance says impact-resistant roofs may be eligible for discounts, and each insurance company sets its own. Call your agent before you decide and ask how much the credit would be and what paperwork they need.
Can my HOA stop me from using impact-resistant shingles?
Generally no. Texas Property Code section 202.011 says an HOA can't prohibit shingles designed to resist wind and hail. It can require that they look like the shingles allowed in the neighborhood and are equal or better in quality. You may still need architectural approval.
Are impact-resistant shingles hail-proof?
No. Very large or wind-driven hail can still damage them. They are tested to take a harder hit than standard shingles before cracking, which can mean fewer repairs after moderate hail.
Is a Class 3 shingle the same as Class 4?
No. Class 3 passed the test with a 1.75-inch ball, one step below Class 4. Some insurers give a credit for Class 3 and some only for Class 4. Ask your agent which ratings they accept before you pick a product.
Have a leak, storm damage or a project in mind?
Free inspections and written estimates, with photos of what we find.
