Apex Roofing & Construction Text a photoCall 682-558-1382
Homeowner guide

Hail Size and Roof Damage: What Size Hail Hurts Which Roof?

Updated Oct 8, 2026 by Apex Roofing & Construction. General information for North Texas homeowners, not legal or insurance advice.

Short answerThe National Weather Service calls hail severe at 1 inch, about quarter size. Engineering research puts the damage threshold for common asphalt shingles at about 1 to 1.25 inches, and higher for tile, but that assumes hard hail, a straight-down hit and a roof in decent shape. Older roofs, wind-driven hail and repeated small-hail storms can lower that line. Size alone can't tell you if a roof was damaged.

After a hail storm, people usually ask first how big the hail was. Size matters, but the same stone can leave one roof untouched and crack another. This guide explains what hail size means and what lab and field research says about each roofing material. It also covers the other things that matter as much as size.

If hail just hit, start with our step-by-step guide on what to do after a hail storm in North Texas. For how often big hail falls in your county, see DFW hail history by county.

How is hail size measured?

By diameter, across the widest part of the stone. NOAA's National Severe Storms Laboratory (NSSL) says comparing hail to a common object is good, but a ruler, calipers or tape measure work even better. Here is the full NSSL size chart:

ObjectDiameter
Pea1/4 inch
Mothball1/2 inch
Penny3/4 inch
Nickel7/8 inch
Quarter1 inch (severe)
Ping-pong ball1 1/2 inches
Golf ball1 3/4 inches
Tennis ball2 1/2 inches
Baseball2 3/4 inches
Tea cup3 inches
Softball4 inches
Grapefruit4 1/2 inches

The National Weather Service defines a severe thunderstorm as one with hail at least 1 inch in diameter, winds of at least 58 mph, or a tornado. That 1 inch line is a weather term. It is not a promise that smaller hail did no harm, or that bigger hail always did.

How fast does hail hit?

Faster as it gets bigger. NSSL says hail of 1 to 1.75 inches, the size seen in a typical severe storm, falls at about 25 to 40 mph. Stones of 2 to 4 inches fall at about 44 to 72 mph. Very large hail over 4 inches can top 100 mph. Shape, melting and wind all change the real speed.

At what size does hail damage each roof type?

Engineers who study hail use "threshold sizes," the smallest hail likely to cause damage to a material. A 2013 paper published by IIBEC, a building envelope industry group, lists these threshold sizes:

  • Three-tab asphalt shingles: 1 inch
  • Laminated (architectural) asphalt shingles: 1 1/4 inches
  • Wood shingles: 1 1/4 inches
  • Clay tile: 1 1/2 inches
  • Concrete tile: 1 3/4 inches

Treat those as a starting point. Researchers base them on hard hail, straight-on hits, a well-supported roof and a roof in relatively good shape. Change any of those and damage can start at a smaller size.

What has IBHS found in its hail lab?

The Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety (IBHS) tests roofing products in its own hail lab, using lab-made hailstones. Key findings from its hail impact summary:

  1. 1.5 inch hail: Every new shingle tested, impact-rated or not, rated Good or Excellent. New shingles should offer good protection from hail this size or smaller.
  2. 2 inch hail: Products started to separate. Every impact-rated shingle rated Good or Excellent at this size was made with polymer-modified asphalt.
  3. What kind of damage matters: New products all scored well on granule loss. Dents, ridges and tears scored worst, and IBHS says those are the types of damage most directly tied to water getting through.

IBHS also notes that its lab hail matches natural hail in non-wind-driven conditions. Wind changes the picture, as covered below.

What do Class 1 to Class 4 ratings mean?

Most impact ratings come from UL 2218. Steel balls are dropped twice on the same spot, from the height needed to match the energy of real hail. The ball sizes are 1.25 inches for Class 1, 1.5 for Class 2, 1.75 for Class 3 and 2 inches for Class 4. A product fails if a crack, tear or rupture shows on the back of the shingle. Dents and crushed granules on top do not count as failures.

A similar test, FM 4473, fires balls of pure ice and uses the same four classes, according to IBHS. It covers tile as well as shingles. IBHS points out that both standards test new products and do not account for weathering or aging. Our guide to Class 4 impact-resistant shingles in Texas covers cost, HOA rules and insurance credits.

Why does roof age matter so much?

The 2013 IIBEC paper notes that asphalt shingles become more brittle with time as they weather. A newer IBHS study tested what repeated small hail does. Roofs exposed to natural weathering and repeated rounds of sub-severe hail, under 1 inch, became up to ten times more susceptible to damage from later large hail than new shingles.

Granules make the difference. Small hail knocks them loose, and IBHS says that leaves the asphalt exposed to weathering. That is the difference between two kinds of damage:

  • Granule loss wears the shingle's sun shield. It may not leak today, but the shingle ages faster.
  • A fracture or tear in the shingle mat is an opening. That is the kind of damage most likely to let water in.

How do other roofing materials respond?

Metal. Dents are common, but not every dent is a failure. A 2025 study in IIBEC Interface found that dents from hail 2.5 inches or smaller did not make Galvalume-coated steel corrode faster. One case was the steel roof of a Fort Worth strip shopping center, hit in the May 1995 Mayfest storm by hail at least 2.5 inches across, and possibly up to 4 inches. When the roof was checked 27 years later, the authors found no corrosion at the dents. They treat such dents as cosmetic unless they open a path for water. Punctures, split seams and bent flashing are functional problems.

Tile. Tile does not dent. It cracks or breaks. The threshold list above puts clay tile at 1 1/2 inches and concrete tile at 1 3/4 inches. Cracked tiles can let water reach the underlayment below.

Wood shingles. Hail can split wood shingles. The listed threshold is 1 1/4 inches, the same as laminated asphalt shingles.

How does wind change hail damage?

Strong wind drives hail at an angle, or even nearly sideways. NSSL says wind-driven hail can tear up siding, break windows and blow into houses. On a roof, it means the slopes facing the storm can take most of the hits while the back slopes look fine. It also means walls, windows and screens on one side of the house may show damage the roof does not.

What clues show how big the hail was?

Soft metal is a good witness. InterNACHI notes that hard hail hitting soft, thin materials, such as aluminum vents, leaves a better indication of its diameter than hail hitting hard materials. From the ground, look at:

  1. Dents in gutters and downspouts.
  2. Dents on roof vents, flashing and window wraps.
  3. Torn window screens.
  4. Damage on one side of the house more than the others.

Soft metal dents prove hail fell. They do not prove the roof covering itself was damaged. A close inspection of the shingles is still needed.

What about insurance and cosmetic damage?

Read your policy. Texas has approved optional endorsements that exclude cosmetic hail damage to impact-resistant roof coverings, meaning damage that changes how the roof looks but does not let water through or stop it from working. They apply to homes getting a premium credit for an impact-rated roof, and the policyholder must sign them. Ask your agent whether your policy has one. Our roof insurance claim guide explains how claims work in Texas.

What should I do next?

  1. Measure a few stones with a ruler if you can do it safely, and photograph them.
  2. Check soft metals and the storm-facing side of the house from the ground.
  3. Think about your roof's age and past storms. An older roof can be damaged by smaller hail.
  4. Have the roof inspected up close. Dents, tears and fractures matter more than a few loose granules.

Common questions

What size hail is considered severe?

The National Weather Service defines a severe thunderstorm as one with hail at least 1 inch in diameter, winds of at least 58 mph, or a tornado. NOAA's storm lab says hail the size of a quarter or larger is severe.

What size hail damages asphalt shingles?

A 2013 engineering paper lists about 1 inch as the smallest hail likely to damage three-tab shingles and 1 1/4 inches for laminated shingles. Those numbers assume hard hail hitting straight on and a roof in fairly good shape. In IBHS lab tests, new shingles of both kinds held up well to 1.5 inch hail.

Do hail dents on a metal roof mean it needs replacing?

Not always. A 2025 study in IIBEC Interface found dents from hail 2.5 inches or smaller did not speed up corrosion of Galvalume-coated steel panels, including a Fort Worth shopping center roof hit in 1995. Dents that only change the look are often called cosmetic. Punctures, open seams or damage that lets water in are a different matter.

Can small hail damage a roof?

Over time, yes. IBHS research found that roofs exposed to natural weathering and repeated hail under 1 inch became up to ten times more susceptible to damage from later large hail than new shingles. Small hail knocks off granules, which leaves the asphalt open to sun and weather.

Does insurance cover cosmetic hail damage?

It depends on your policy. Texas has approved optional endorsements that exclude hail damage that changes how an impact-resistant roof looks but does not let water in or stop it from working. Read your policy or ask your agent whether yours has a cosmetic damage exclusion.

Sources

  1. NOAA National Severe Storms Laboratory: Severe Weather 101, Hail Basics (accessed Oct 8, 2026)
  2. National Weather Service: Glossary, Severe Thunderstorm (accessed Oct 8, 2026)
  3. IBHS: Hail impact performance of asphalt shingles, at a glance (2020, PDF) (accessed Oct 8, 2026)
  4. IBHS: Relative impact resistance of asphalt shingles, summary of UL 2218 tests (Aug 2014, PDF) (accessed Oct 8, 2026)
  5. IBHS: Roof 101 (UL 2218 and FM 4473 impact tests) (accessed Oct 8, 2026)
  6. IBHS: Impact testing of high concentrations of small hail (accessed Oct 8, 2026)
  7. IIBEC: Asphalt composition shingle damage, hail or manufacturing defect? (Darrell L. Smith, 15 May 2013) (accessed Oct 8, 2026)
  8. IIBEC Interface: A deep dive into hail-caused dents in Galvalume-coated steel roof panels (Beckner and Patterson, Fall 2025) (accessed Oct 8, 2026)
  9. InterNACHI: Mastering roof inspections, hail damage part 3 (Shepard and Gromicko) (accessed Oct 8, 2026)
  10. Texas Department of Insurance: Commissioner's Bulletin B-0030-98, cosmetic damage exclusion endorsements (accessed Oct 8, 2026)

Have a leak, storm damage or a project in mind?

Free inspections and written estimates, with photos of what we find.