Apex Roofing & Construction Text a photoCall 682-558-1382
Homeowner guide

How to Read a Roofing Estimate and Compare Bids

Updated Oct 8, 2026 by Apex Roofing & Construction. General information for North Texas homeowners, not legal or insurance advice.

Short answerA good roofing estimate lists the roof size in squares, the waste factor, how many layers come off, a per-sheet price for bad decking, the underlayment, drip edge, starter, ridge cap, flashing, vents, pipe boots, permit, disposal and cleanup. Line up bids item by item for the same scope before you compare totals. In Texas, the contractor must give you a written rights disclosure before you sign, and you hold back 10 percent until 30 days after the work is done.

Laws and city rules change. For a specific contract, talk to a Texas attorney.

A roofing estimate can look like a wall of numbers. Two bids for the same house can differ by thousands of dollars. Often they just cover different work. One bid includes new flashing and vents, and the other quietly reuses them. This guide goes through the lines you are likely to see and what each one means. Then it shows how to compare bids fairly.

What should a roofing estimate include?

A roofing proposal should spell out the work, the materials and any extra terms. GAF's homeowner guide lists the standard parts of a replacement as a full tear-off, new shingles, ridge cap, underlayment, drip edge, flashing and final cleanup. The same guide names common extras: rotten decking, gutter work and major ventilation changes.

The Texas Attorney General gives similar advice. Get bids in writing, look for detail about exactly what will be done, and consider naming the grade of materials. TDI adds that the contract should list the materials they will use.

What does each line on the estimate mean?

Line itemWhat it isWhat to check
Squares1 square = 100 sq ft of roofTotal squares match between bids
Waste factorExtra material for cutsStated as a percent
Tear-offRemoving old layersNumber of layers
DeckingWood deck panelsPrice per sheet, thickness
UnderlaymentWater-resistant layer under shinglesBrand and type
Drip edgeMetal strip at eaves and rakesNew, included
Starter stripFirst course at the edgesBrand matches shingles
Ridge capShingles at the peaks and hipsBrand matches shingles
FlashingMetal at walls, chimneys, valleysNew or reused
VentsIntake and exhaustType and count
Pipe bootsSeals around plumbing ventsNew
Permit, disposal, cleanupFees, dumpster, nail sweepWho pulls the permit

Squares, bundles and waste

A square is the material that covers 100 square feet of roof. Fine Homebuilding notes that many shingles come three bundles to the square, while heavier shingles take four or five. Your roof has more squares than your floor plan suggests, because of slope and overhangs.

The waste factor covers shingles cut off at hips, valleys and edges. A simple gable roof wastes less than a cut-up roof with many hips and valleys. If one bid has far more squares than another, ask each contractor how they measured and what waste they used.

Tear-off and layers

The residential code calls for removing existing roof coverings down to the deck before re-roofing, unless an exception applies. Arlington's bulletin quotes the code. It does not allow a new layer over an old one where the roof already has two or more applications of any type of roof covering. Each extra layer means more labor and dump fees, so the estimate should state how many come off.

Decking

Rotten or broken decking is a common surprise cost. GAF notes that most contractors charge a per-sheet rate because no one can see the wood until the shingles are off. Get that price in writing.

City rules matter here. Fort Worth's re-roofing FAQ says sound sheathing that met code when built does not have to be replaced, that new decking cannot be laid over an old layer, and that a permit is required if any decking is replaced. Arlington says damaged decking must be replaced with at least 7/16 inch panels rated for the span.

Underlayment, drip edge and ice barrier

Fort Worth requires underlayment that meets either the shingle maker's instructions or the residential code, whichever is stricter. Fort Worth also requires drip edge and crickets when re-roofing, even if the old roof had none. A cricket is a small ridge that sends water around a chimney. The code calls for one on the uphill side of any chimney or penetration more than 30 inches wide.

Fort Worth and Arlington both say an ice barrier underlayment is not required locally, because the area has no history of ice damming. Some bids still use self-adhered membrane in valleys or around chimneys. That is a choice, so ask where it goes.

Starter, ridge cap and nails

Starter strips and matching ridge cap can affect your warranty. Manufacturers tie wind coverage to them. Owens Corning's standard shingle warranty, for example, says the higher wind rating on one of its lines applies only with six nails per shingle and its starter product along eaves and rakes. If a bid lists a high wind rating, check that the nailing and starter match.

Flashing, vents and pipe boots

Arlington's bulletin cites the code rule that flashing must be rebuilt following the manufacturer's instructions. GAF says flashing around chimneys and valleys is typically replaced, not reused. Ask for "new" in writing for flashing and pipe boots.

For vents, the Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association cites a common minimum of 1 square foot of vent area per 150 square feet of attic floor. Replacing existing vents is usually included. Adding soffit intake or cutting a new ridge vent often costs extra. See our attic ventilation guide.

Permit, disposal and cleanup

Permit rules vary by city. See roof permits by city. Disposal covers the dumpster and dump fees. Cleanup should include a sweep for nails.

How do I compare bids side by side?

  1. Get at least three written bids. TDI says this helps you spot offers that are too high or too good to be true.
  2. Put every bid in the table above, one column each.
  3. Circle anything missing or marked "reuse."
  4. Check the shingle brand, product line and impact rating.
  5. Compare the decking price per sheet.
  6. Compare warranties, both manufacturer and workmanship. Our roof warranty guide explains the difference.
  7. Only then compare totals.

Be careful with the low outlier. The Attorney General warns that a very low bidder may skip tasks or use cheaper labor or materials, and that most honest bids fall in a fairly close range.

What are the red flags on an estimate?

  • Blank spaces in the contract. The Attorney General says never sign one.
  • A price of "whatever insurance pays." TDI warns against contracts for your insurance payment.
  • An offer to cover your deductible. That is illegal in Texas.
  • A large or full payment before work starts.
  • No product names, only "shingles."
  • Pressure to sign today.

What payment terms are normal in Texas?

  1. Rights disclosure. Before you sign a residential construction contract, the contractor must give you a written disclosure statement under Property Code 53.255. It says an oral promise left out of the written agreement may not be enforceable.
  2. Deposit. The Attorney General says a partial payment up front is common, except in some post-disaster cases, but you should not pay in full until the work is complete and you have inspected it.
  3. 10 percent reserve. Property Code 53.101 has the owner reserve 10 percent of the contract price during the work and for 30 days after completion.
  4. Bills-paid affidavit. At final payment, the contractor must give you an affidavit that bills are paid.
  5. Certificate of completion. Do not sign one until the work is finished and the site is clean.

Our guide to your rights when you hire a contractor in Texas covers lien waivers and the construction account rule.

What changes if insurance is paying?

If a contract of $1,000 or more is expected to be paid at least partly by a property insurance claim, Business and Commerce Code 27.02 requires a notice in at least 12-point bold type saying you must pay your deductible. Your insurer's estimate and a contractor's bid are separate documents. Questions about what your policy pays go to your insurer or agent. Our roof insurance claim guide explains the process.

Common questions

What is a square on a roofing estimate?

A square is the amount of roofing that covers 100 square feet of roof surface. Many shingles come three bundles to the square, and heavier shingles can take four or five bundles per square.

Why does my estimate charge extra for decking?

Nobody can see the condition of the wood deck until the old roof is off. So most contractors list a price per sheet for any rotten or broken decking they find. Ask for that price in writing before you sign, so the extra cost is not a surprise.

Is drip edge required on a re-roof in Fort Worth?

Yes. The City of Fort Worth's re-roofing FAQ says drip edge and crickets are required when re-roofing even if the old roof did not have them. The same FAQ says an ice barrier underlayment is not required in Fort Worth.

How much should I pay a roofer up front in Texas?

There is no single legal number for most jobs. The Texas Attorney General says a partial payment in advance is common, but you should not pay in full until the work is complete and you have inspected it. Texas law also has you reserve 10 percent of the contract price until 30 days after completion.

Should the cheapest roofing bid win?

Not by itself. The Texas Attorney General warns that a bid far below the others may leave out tasks or use cheaper labor or materials, and says most honest bids land in a fairly close range. Line up the items first, then compare price.

Sources

  1. GAF RoofViews: What's included in a roof replacement? (Dawn Killough, 24 Jul 2026) (accessed Oct 8, 2026)
  2. Fine Homebuilding: Don't fall short on shingles, how to estimate materials (Mike Guertin) (accessed Oct 8, 2026)
  3. City of Fort Worth: Residential re-roofing FAQ (PDF) (accessed Oct 8, 2026)
  4. City of Arlington: Re-roof permits, inspections and common Q&A (technical bulletin, 13 Sep 2023, PDF) (accessed Oct 8, 2026)
  5. UpCodes: 2021 International Residential Code as adopted in Texas, Chapter 9 Roof Assemblies (R903.2.2 crickets, R905.2.8.5 drip edge) (accessed Oct 8, 2026)
  6. Owens Corning: Standard Product Limited Lifetime Warranty (Pub. 10023873, Aug 2026, PDF) (accessed Oct 8, 2026)
  7. Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association: Attic space ventilation is key to cooling a roof (Oct 2023, PDF) (accessed Oct 8, 2026)
  8. Texas Attorney General: How to avoid home improvement scams (accessed Oct 8, 2026)
  9. Texas Department of Insurance: How to avoid contracting scams (accessed Oct 8, 2026)
  10. Texas Property Code Sec. 53.255, Disclosure statement required for residential construction contracts (accessed Oct 8, 2026)
  11. Texas Property Code Sec. 53.101, Required retainage (accessed Oct 8, 2026)
  12. Texas Business and Commerce Code Sec. 27.02, Payment of deductible required (accessed Oct 8, 2026)

Have a leak, storm damage or a project in mind?

Free inspections and written estimates, with photos of what we find.