Apex Roofing & Construction Text a photoCall 682-558-1382
Homeowner guide

Roof Repair or Replacement: How to Decide

Updated Oct 7, 2026 by Apex Roofing & Construction. General information for North Texas homeowners, not legal or insurance advice.

Short answerRepair makes sense when the damage is limited to one area and the rest of the roof is sound and not near the end of its life. Replacement makes more sense when the roof is near the end of its expected life, damage or wear is spread across many slopes, the decking is soft, or you keep paying for new leaks. A close inspection with photos should drive the decision.

Roof problems often start small, like a few missing shingles after a windy night, a stain on the ceiling or a cracked pipe boot. The question is whether fixing that one spot is money well spent, or whether the whole roof is near the end.

When is a roof repair enough?

A repair is usually the right call when most of these are true:

  • The damage is in one area, like one slope or around one chimney or vent.
  • The rest of the shingles still lie flat, hold their granules and are not brittle.
  • The decking under the damaged area is solid, not soft or sagging.
  • The roof is well short of its expected life (see the table below).
  • This is the first leak, or the first in a long time.

Common repairs include replacing wind-blown shingles, resealing or replacing flashing, replacing cracked pipe boots, and fixing a small area of damaged decking.

When does replacing the roof make more sense?

Replacement tends to win when several of these are true:

  • The roof is close to or past its expected life.
  • Wear shows on many slopes. NRCA lists curling or splitting shingles and dislodged or missing tabs as signs of asphalt roof wear.
  • You have had several leaks in different places.
  • The decking feels soft or you can see daylight in the attic.
  • Storm damage is spread across most of the roof.
  • The roof already has two layers, so it cannot be covered again.

How long should my roof last before I replace it?

InterNACHI, a home inspector group, publishes these rough guidelines. It notes that real life depends on local weather, design, material quality and maintenance.

Roof typeEstimated life
Asphalt, three-tab20 years
Asphalt, architectural30 years
Metal40 to 80 years
Clay or concrete tile100+ years
Wood25 years
Modified bitumen (low slope)20 years

North Texas heat and hail can shorten these. See how long a roof lasts in Texas.

How do I decide, step by step?

  1. Get a close inspection with photos. Ask for photos of every problem and every slope, plus the attic if it is accessible. Our inspection guide explains what a good report includes.
  2. Find out the roof's age. Check closing papers, permits, old invoices or the manufacturer's warranty paperwork.
  3. Map the damage. Note if it is on one slope or all of them, and if you have one leak or several.
  4. Price both options. Get a written repair quote and a written replacement quote from the same contractor, and at least one more bid on whichever you lean toward.
  5. Check how long the repair will last. Ask the contractor, in writing, what the repair covers and for how long.
  6. Think about insurance. As roofs age, TDI says some companies switch roof coverage to actual cash value, and they may charge more or refuse coverage based on roof condition. An old roof can cost you at renewal as well as at claim time.
  7. Check permits. Ask the contractor whether your city requires one for the work.

Can I put a new roof over the old one?

Sometimes, but the code limits it. Arlington's re-roof bulletin quotes section R908 of the 2021 International Residential Code, which both Arlington and Fort Worth have adopted. A replacement normally means removing all layers down to the deck. A re-cover over the old roof is not allowed when:

  1. The existing roof is water-soaked or too deteriorated to be a good base.
  2. The existing roof is slate, clay, cement or asbestos-cement tile.
  3. The roof already has two or more layers.

Even when a re-cover is allowed, it hides the decking. You lose the chance to find and fix rot.

Do I need a permit for a roof repair?

It depends on the city and the scope.

  • Fort Worth: the city's re-roofing FAQ says no permit is needed when only shingles are replaced on a one- or two-family home. A permit is needed if any decking is replaced.
  • Arlington: a permit is required to replace roof covering unless the area replaced is 10 percent or less of the roof. Arlington also says all re-roofing work must meet code, even when no permit is needed.

Other towns set their own rules. Ask the contractor who will pull the permit, and get it in writing.

Does the roof have to meet today's code if I only repair part of it?

Not automatically. Both Fort Worth and Arlington say that if your roof met code when it was built, it is still in compliance under the International Existing Building Code. Fort Worth adds that sheathing in good condition does not need to be replaced. New work, though, must meet current code. You may have heard of a "25 percent rule." Our 25% rule guide explains where that idea comes from and why it is not the rule in Fort Worth or Arlington.

What does waiting cost?

A small leak left alone can wet insulation, drywall and framing. The EPA says to dry water-damaged areas within 24 to 48 hours to prevent mold. A repair you put off can turn into a ceiling repair too.

How does insurance fit into repair or replace?

Insurance pays for covered sudden damage, such as hail or wind, under your policy's terms. It does not pay to replace a roof that is simply worn out.

How much you get also depends on your coverage type. TDI's example shows that on an actual cash value policy, a roof that costs $10,000 to replace is worth $7,000 at 10 years old and $4,000 at 20 years old before the deductible. With a $4,000 deductible, that 20-year-old roof would pay nothing.

If a storm caused the damage, start with our roof insurance claim guide.

Common questions

How old is too old to repair a roof?

There is no legal cutoff. InterNACHI's life expectancy chart lists about 20 years for three-tab asphalt shingles and about 30 years for architectural shingles. Once a roof is close to those ages and has wear on many slopes, repairs tend to buy less time.

Can I put new shingles over my old roof instead of replacing it?

Sometimes. The residential code allows a re-cover only in limited cases. It is not allowed if the old roof is water-soaked or deteriorated, if it is slate, clay, cement or asbestos-cement tile, or if it already has two or more layers. Ask your city what it allows.

Do I need a permit to repair my roof?

It depends on the city and the size of the job. Fort Worth says no permit is needed for shingle-only work on a one- or two-family home but one is needed if decking is replaced. Arlington does not require a permit when the area replaced is 10 percent or less of the roof.

Will insurance replace my whole roof if part of it is damaged?

Insurance pays for covered damage under your policy terms. It does not pay for normal wear. How much of the roof is covered depends on the adjuster's findings and your policy. If you disagree with a decision, talk to your insurer first.

Is it worth repairing a roof if I plan to sell soon?

Often, a sound repair is enough, but buyers' inspectors and insurers look at roof condition. TDI says insurers may charge more or refuse coverage based on what they see on a roof, which can affect a buyer.

Sources

  1. InterNACHI: Standard estimated life expectancy chart for homes (accessed Oct 7, 2026)
  2. NRCA Professional Roofing, Tech Today (Mark S. Graham, Oct 2013): inspection advice (accessed Oct 7, 2026)
  3. City of Arlington: Re-roof permits, inspections and common Q&A (13 Sep 2023, PDF) (accessed Oct 7, 2026)
  4. City of Fort Worth: Residential re-roofing FAQ (PDF) (accessed Oct 7, 2026)
  5. Texas Department of Insurance: Insurance and your roof (updated 1 Apr 2026) (accessed Oct 7, 2026)
  6. Texas Department of Insurance: Home policies, replacement cost or actual cash value? (24 Jan 2024) (accessed Oct 7, 2026)
  7. U.S. EPA: A brief guide to mold, moisture and your home (accessed Oct 7, 2026)

Have a leak, storm damage or a project in mind?

Free inspections and written estimates, with photos of what we find.