Apex Roofing & Construction Text a photoCall 682-558-1382
Homeowner guide

What Is the 25% Rule for Roofing, and Does It Apply in Texas?

Updated Oct 7, 2026 by Apex Roofing & Construction. General information for North Texas homeowners, not legal or insurance advice.

Short answerThe '25% rule' comes from the Florida Building Code, which said no more than 25 percent of a roof could be repaired or replaced in 12 months unless the whole roof met current code, and Florida loosened it in 2022. It is not part of the residential code Fort Worth and Arlington use (2021 IRC, section R908). We found no Texas law that makes an insurer replace a whole roof once 25 percent is damaged. What gets paid depends on your policy and the damage.

The "25% rule" comes up often when people research roofing in North Texas, and some websites describe it as Texas law. It is not, at least not in the code that Fort Worth and Arlington publish. Here is where the rule really comes from, what our local cities actually require, and how insurance fits in.

Where does the 25% rule come from?

It comes from Florida. A 2022 Florida House staff analysis quotes the Florida Building Code rule. It said not more than 25 percent of the total roof area or roof section could be repaired, replaced or recovered in any 12-month period, unless the entire roof or roof section met the current code.

In practice, if more than a quarter of a Florida roof was damaged and the rest of the roof did not meet today's code, the whole roof had to be replaced.

In 2022, Florida changed this. A state law (SB 4-D) added an exception that took effect May 27, 2022, according to the Florida Roofing and Sheet Metal Contractors Association. If the rest of the roof meets at least the 2007 Florida Building Code, you can repair or replace part of it without bringing the whole roof up to the current code.

Is there a 25% roof rule in Texas?

We did not find one in the codes and city guidance for our area.

  • The model residential code. Fort Worth and Arlington both point to the 2021 International Residential Code. Its reroofing section, R908, covers when old roofing must be removed, when a new roof may go over an old one, and how flashing is rebuilt. NRCA's summary of the reroofing rules in the I-codes lists no 25 percent repair threshold (Professional Roofing, 2019).
  • Regional amendments. The North Central Texas Council of Governments publishes recommended local changes to the 2021 IRC for cities in our region. Its roofing change is to section R902.1 (roof covering classes). We found no change to R908 and no 25 percent rule (NCTCOG 2021 IRC amendments).
  • City guidance. Neither Fort Worth's nor Arlington's re-roofing FAQ mentions a 25 percent rule.

Every city adopts and amends its own codes, though. If you live outside Fort Worth or Arlington, ask your building department.

What do Fort Worth and Arlington actually require?

Both cities answer the real question behind the 25% rule, which is whether an older roof has to be brought up to today's code.

QuestionFort WorthArlington
Does an older roof have to meet current code?If it met code when built, it is still in compliance under the International Existing Building CodeSame answer
Must all old decking be replaced?No, not if it is in good conditionNo, not if it is in good condition; damaged decking must be replaced to current code
Permit for re-roofing?Not for shingle-only work on a one- or two-family home; yes if any decking is replacedYes, unless the area replaced is 10 percent or less of the roof
Code items added when re-roofingDrip edge and crickets required if missingFlashing and drip edge required; underlayment replaced when re-shingling

Sources: Fort Worth re-roofing FAQ and Arlington re-roof bulletin.

So the local rule is closer to this: the part you repair or replace must meet current code, and the rest of a roof that met code when built can stay. Arlington adds that all re-roofing work must meet code, even when no permit is required.

When does the code require removing the whole roof?

The 2021 IRC rules quoted in Arlington's bulletin say a roof replacement means removing existing layers down to the deck. A new roof cannot be installed over the old one when:

  1. the existing roof is water-soaked or too deteriorated to be a good base,
  2. the existing roof is slate, clay, cement or asbestos-cement tile, or
  3. the roof already has two or more layers.

These rules are about condition and layers, not a percentage of damage.

Does insurance use a 25% rule in Texas?

We found no Texas statute that requires an insurer to replace a whole roof once a set percentage is damaged. What an insurer pays depends on:

  • Your policy. Replacement cost or actual cash value, your deductible, and any exclusions.
  • What the adjuster finds. How much of the roof has covered damage, and whether it can be repaired.
  • Cosmetic damage exclusions. Some Texas policies exclude hail damage that only alters the appearance of the roof without letting water in.

If you think the insurer's scope is wrong, ask for its reasoning in writing and provide your own photos and a written repair estimate. Your policy may allow appraisal for disputes over the amount. You can also talk to a licensed public adjuster or an attorney. Note that Texas does not allow a roofing contractor to negotiate your claim for you.

What is ordinance or law coverage, and do I need it?

When a repair must meet current code, some work may cost more than simply replacing what was there. Examples include adding drip edge or crickets that the old roof did not have. Coverage for those extra costs is usually optional.

TDI's home insurance guide lists an endorsement for extra construction or repair costs to meet local building codes. This is often called ordinance or law coverage. Check your declarations page or ask your agent whether you have it and how much it pays.

When does a partial repair turn into a full replacement?

Even without a 25% rule, a repair can grow into a replacement. Common reasons:

  1. The shingles are too brittle to work. Old asphalt shingles can crack when lifted to weave in new ones.
  2. The damage is on most slopes. Patching many areas can cost close to a new roof.
  3. The decking is bad. Soft or broken decking must be replaced to current code.
  4. The roof already has two layers. It cannot be covered again.
  5. Matching. Discontinued colors or styles may not blend. How a policy handles matching depends on its wording, so ask your adjuster.

Ask your contractor to explain in writing why a repair will or will not work, with photos.

How do I check the rules for my city?

  1. Find your city's building or development services page and search for "re-roof" or "roofing."
  2. Note which code edition the city has adopted and any local amendments.
  3. Ask whether a permit is required for the size of your job.
  4. Ask whether any parts of the roof must be upgraded during the work.
  5. Keep the answers with your contract and permit.

For a side-by-side look at local rules, see our page on roof permits by city.

Common questions

What is the 25% rule for roofing?

It is a Florida Building Code provision. It said no more than 25 percent of a roof or roof section could be repaired, replaced or recovered in any 12 months unless the entire roof or section met the current code. A 2022 Florida law added an exception for roofs built to the 2007 Florida code or later.

Is there a 25% roof rule in Texas?

Not in the model residential code used by Fort Worth and Arlington. The reroofing section of the 2021 International Residential Code (R908) has no 25 percent threshold. Both cities say a roof that met code when built is still compliant under the International Existing Building Code.

Does my insurance company have to replace my whole roof if 25% is damaged?

We found no Texas statute that says so. Insurers pay for covered damage under the policy terms, based on what the adjuster finds. If you disagree, ask for the reason in writing, check your policy's appraisal clause, or talk to a licensed public adjuster or an attorney.

What is ordinance or law coverage?

It is optional coverage that helps pay extra costs to bring repairs up to current building codes. TDI lists it as an endorsement for extra construction or repair costs to meet local building codes. Without it, code upgrades may not be covered.

Do I need a permit for a partial roof repair in Fort Worth?

Fort Worth's re-roofing FAQ says no permit is needed for shingle-only work on a one- or two-family home, and a permit is needed if any decking is replaced. In Arlington, a permit is not needed when the replaced area is 10 percent or less of the roof.

Sources

  1. Florida House of Representatives: Staff analysis of HB 3D (2022), roof repair, replacement and recovering requirements (PDF) (accessed Oct 7, 2026)
  2. Florida Roofing and Sheet Metal Contractors Association: Current and coming changes to the 25% rule (Mike Silvers, 24 Mar 2023) (accessed Oct 7, 2026)
  3. City of Fort Worth: Residential re-roofing FAQ (PDF) (accessed Oct 7, 2026)
  4. City of Arlington: Re-roof permits, inspections and common Q&A (13 Sep 2023, PDF) (accessed Oct 7, 2026)
  5. North Central Texas Council of Governments: 2021 IRC regional amendments, approved July 2021 (PDF) (accessed Oct 7, 2026)
  6. NRCA Professional Roofing: Reroofing by the book (Mark S. Graham, Feb 2019) (accessed Oct 7, 2026)
  7. Texas Department of Insurance: Home insurance guide (updated 1 Jun 2026) (accessed Oct 7, 2026)
  8. Texas Department of Insurance: Commissioner's Bulletin B-0030-98, cosmetic damage exclusion endorsements (accessed Oct 7, 2026)
  9. Texas Department of Insurance: Roofing and insurance, know the law (accessed Oct 7, 2026)

Have a leak, storm damage or a project in mind?

Free inspections and written estimates, with photos of what we find.