Apex Roofing & Construction Text a photoCall 682-558-1382
Fort Worth neighborhood

Roofing and Foundation Work on Elizabeth Boulevard

Elizabeth Boulevard was Fort Worth's first city historic district, and tile roofs are part of its original look. Its standards spell out what a roof replacement can and cannot change.

Short answerElizabeth Boulevard is a City of Fort Worth historic district with its own standards. Roofing must be replaced with the same type of material, such as tile to tile, and any change, such as tile to composition, goes to the Historic and Cultural Landmarks Commission. In-kind replacements can get administrative approval from the city's preservation office, and metal roofs are not allowed except metal made to look like historic clay tile.

Fort Worth's first historic district

Elizabeth Boulevard runs seven blocks between Eighth Avenue and College Avenue, inside the Ryan Place Addition on the near south side. Developer John C. Ryan named it for his wife. He bought the land in 1909, and the first house was started in May 1911, the same year the stone entry gates went up. The National Register nomination says most homes were built from 1911 to 1929, with a peak around 1919 and 1920, after oil was found in West Texas. Building stopped with the 1929 crash, and the last empty lots filled after 1950 with one-story masonry houses.

The nomination counted 44 houses on 26 acres, on lots of at least 60 by 140 feet. It calls the boulevard the city's oldest restricted subdivision and the first in Fort Worth to use landscape architects and to put utilities in the alleys. Prairie School houses are the most common. There are also Georgian Revival, Spanish Colonial Revival and Mission Revival homes, plus a few large Mediterranean-style villas. The common threads, in the nomination's words, are brick construction, tile roofs and one-story porches.

The city adopted district standards on August 12, 1980, and revised them on August 9, 2007. Their stated goal is to keep the boulevard's feel as the "Silk Stocking Row of the 1920's."

The roofing standards

The Elizabeth Boulevard standards have a full roof section. In plain words:

  1. Keep the existing roofline and the features that give the roof its character. Roof shape, slope and pitch must fit the style and period of the house.
  2. Keep original fireplace chimneys and other features that add to the style.
  3. Replace roofing with the same type of material. The example given is tile to tile.
  4. Any change in material, such as tile to composition, is reviewed by the Historic and Cultural Landmarks Commission.
  5. Roof materials and colors must fit the style and period. Metal is not allowed, except historic replica styles such as metal made to look like clay tile.
  6. A roof replacement must keep the same overhang as the existing roof.
  7. Attic fans or turbines go on a side or rear roof. Skylights must not be visible from the street.

A separate section covers roof-mounted equipment, including solar devices and antennas. It must be inconspicuous from the street and cannot damage or hide character-defining features.

Who approves what

The standards set three levels of review:

  • Routine maintenance with no change: no added Certificate of Appropriateness (COA), though city permits may apply.
  • In-kind replacement: administrative approval from the city's preservation office.
  • Design changes: talk first with the Elizabeth Boulevard Committee, then submit to the preservation office or the commission. The committee is seven residents, one per block, and is a standing committee of the Ryan Place Improvement Association.

The city's historic preservation page lists roofing among exterior work that needs a COA, taken through the Accela Citizen Access portal. Staff handle most cases, with no published review time. Commission cases follow the monthly calendar: deadline the third Monday, hearing the second Monday of the next month. Questions go to [email protected] or 817-392-8000.

What this means for a tile roof

On this street, a worn tile roof usually means a tile roof again. The National Park Service's clay tile brief has practical advice for owners. It says tiles break under careless foot traffic, falling limbs and heavy hail. When the fastening system fails, the tiles come off, get numbered and are relaid with new corrosion-resistant fasteners. Flashing, gutters and valleys go in before the tile. Matching tiles can sometimes be found through salvage suppliers, using the maker's stamp on the back.

For the 1950s houses with shingle roofs, like-for-like composition is the in-kind case. Either way, keep the overhang the same. In Fort Worth, a shingles-only re-roof on a one- or two-family home needs no permit, but replacing decking does, per the city's re-roofing FAQ.

Pier and beam on Sanger clay

The district standards call the raised pier and beam foundation a distinctive, highly visible feature of the boulevard. They also require new houses to use a raised foundation design.

USDA soil maps place the boulevard on Sanger clay mixed with urban fill. USDA describes Sanger as a very deep clay that takes in water quickly when dry and cracked, and very slowly once wet. Under a pier and beam house, that seasonal swelling and shrinking shows up as sloping floors, doors that will not latch and piers that shift. Keep gutters and downspouts carrying water away from the crawl space. Fort Worth requires a building permit and engineered plans for residential foundation repair, and the city lists foundation work among the changes that need a COA.

Storms nearby

NOAA's Storm Events Database logged 1.5 inch hail about three quarters of a mile northwest of the boulevard on April 19, 2020. On March 17, 2016, hail up to 2.5 inches fell at the Fort Worth Zoo, about a mile and a quarter to the west, in a storm NOAA estimated caused about $600 million in damage in Tarrant County. On October 24, 2025, a National Weather Service survey found large branches down along East Berry Street, about a mile southeast, from gusts estimated at 75 mph.

How we work in historic neighborhoods

Before we price a roof on a street like this, we photograph every slope, the chimneys, the flashing and the eaves, and we measure the existing overhang. The estimate names the material and states that the roof type stays the same, or lays out the choice if you are weighing a change. You can include it with your COA request. The city makes the call, and work waits for it.

Common questions

Can I replace a tile roof on Elizabeth Boulevard with shingles?

Not without commission review. The district standards say existing roofing must be replaced with the same type of material, tile to tile, and that any change in material, such as tile to composition, shall be reviewed by the Historic and Cultural Landmarks Commission.

Is a metal roof allowed on Elizabeth Boulevard?

Generally no. The standards say metal shall not be allowed, except for historic replica styles, such as metal roofing made to look like clay tile. Roof materials and colors must fit the style and period of the house.

Who approves an in-kind roof replacement on Elizabeth Boulevard?

The district standards say routine maintenance with no change needs no added COA, and in-kind replacements can proceed with administrative approval from the city's preservation office. Design changes should be discussed first with the Elizabeth Boulevard Committee, then submitted to the preservation office or the commission. City permits may still be required.

Does a new roof have to keep the same overhang?

Yes. The standards say a roof replacement, addition or alteration shall have an overhang equal to the existing roof's overhang, and it cannot extend over property lines.

Are Elizabeth Boulevard houses pier and beam?

The district standards call the raised foundation of pier and beam construction a distinctive and highly visible feature of the district, and they require new construction to follow a raised foundation design.

Sources

  1. Elizabeth Boulevard Historic District Standards and Design Guidelines (City of Fort Worth; approved Aug. 12, 1980, revised Aug. 9, 2007)
  2. City of Fort Worth, Historic Districts (Elizabeth Boulevard, the city's first historic district)
  3. City of Fort Worth, Historic Preservation (COA list, Accela application, HCLC schedule, contact)
  4. National Register of Historic Places nomination, Elizabeth Boulevard Historic District, ref. 79003010 (Texas Historical Commission Atlas)
  5. National Park Service, Preservation Brief 30: The Preservation and Repair of Historic Clay Tile Roofs
  6. City of Fort Worth, Residential Re-Roofing FAQ (PDF)
  7. City of Fort Worth, Residential Permit Information
  8. USDA NRCS Soil Data Access (map unit 372416, Sanger-Urban land complex, queried at points on the boulevard)
  9. USDA NRCS Official Soil Series Description: Sanger
  10. NOAA NCEI Storm Events Database, event 888728: 1.50 inch hail, south Fort Worth, 19 Apr 2020
  11. NOAA NCEI Storm Events Database, event 625920: 2.50 inch hail at the Fort Worth Zoo, 17 Mar 2016
  12. NOAA NCEI Storm Events Database, event 1297835: thunderstorm wind on East Berry Street, 24 Oct 2025

Have a leak, storm damage or a project in mind?

Free inspections and written estimates, with photos of what we find.