Roofing and Foundation Work in Mistletoe Heights
Mistletoe Heights sits on the bluffs above the Clear Fork of the Trinity, and it has been a city historic district since 2002. Its guidelines ask that roofing be replaced like with like.
A bluff-top neighborhood from the streetcar era
Mistletoe Heights sits on the bluffs above the Clear Fork of the Trinity River, about two miles southwest of downtown. Fort Worth Magazine traces it to 1892, when the Mistletoe Heights Land Company bought the land. It sat mostly empty until 1909, when the city annexed part of it so platting could begin. Lots that first sold for $100 were going for $1,500 by 1926, helped by Texas Christian University's move nearby and the streetcar line that came with it.
The City of Fort Worth made Mistletoe Heights a historic district in 2002 and calls it a strong example of a middle to upper class early 20th century neighborhood. Fort Worth Magazine notes that most homes have brick or stucco exteriors, and that many have basements, which is unusual in North Texas. Historic Fort Worth points out that the most prominent houses line Mistletoe Drive, which winds along the bluff. One of them, built around 1915, is a two-story brick house with a red tile hipped roof. Brick walls, tile or shingle roofs, chimneys and detached garages are the pieces a roofer works around here.
What the guidelines say about roofs
The Mistletoe Heights guidelines are short, and the roof section is clear:
- Preserve the existing roof line and the features that give the roof its character.
- Keep fireplace chimneys, skylights and other elements that add to the style of the house.
- Replace existing roofing with the same type of material. The guidelines give composition to composition as the example.
- Any change in material, such as tile to composition, is reviewed by the Historic and Cultural Landmarks Commission.
- Attic fans or turbines go on a side or rear roof, away from the front of the house.
Two other rules shape the job. Design review focuses on the front and sides of the house, because that is what the street sees. And the guidelines apply when a change in materials, design or outward appearance is visible from a public street. A rear slope that cannot be seen gets more room, but the materials rule still applies.
Do you need a Certificate of Appropriateness?
The guidelines tell owners to contact the city's Historic Preservation Officer during planning, whether or not a building permit is needed, to find out if a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) is required. No building permit is issued until that call is made. The city's current historic preservation page lists roofing among the exterior work that needs a COA. The phone number and office printed in the guidelines are out of date. Use [email protected] or 817-392-8000.
How the review runs:
- Apply online through the city's Accela Citizen Access portal.
- Staff approve most cases. There is no published review time.
- A change of roofing material, or a waiver from the guidelines, goes to the commission. It meets the second Monday of each month, and the application deadline is the third Monday of the month before. Neighbors within 300 feet get a postcard about 10 days ahead.
What this means for a roof replacement
If your house has composition shingles today, a like-for-like composition roof is the simple path. Keep turbines and other vents off the front slopes and say so in the estimate.
If your house has a tile roof, moving to shingles is a commission decision, not a contractor decision. Repair may be an option. The National Park Service's brief on clay tile roofs notes that tiles break under careless foot traffic, falling limbs and heavy hail. When the fasteners fail, it advises taking the tiles off, numbering them, and relaying them with new corrosion-resistant fasteners. Some suppliers stock salvaged tile matched by the maker's stamp on the back.
Fort Worth does not require a permit for a shingles-only re-roof on a one- or two-family home. Replacing decking does, per the city's re-roofing FAQ. Since roofing is on the city's COA list here, ask early how a decking repair found mid-job would be handled.
Ground under the bluff
USDA soil maps show two different grounds in the neighborhood. The sloped bluff land maps as Aledo and Bolar soils mixed with urban fill. USDA describes Aledo as shallow to very shallow and stony, over limestone and marl. A flatter interior area maps as Mingo clay loam, which USDA describes as moderately deep over limestone and marine clay, and which cracks when dry.
So two houses a few blocks apart can sit on very different ground. Near the bluff, the worry is often water running along shallow soil over rock. On the deeper clay, it is the soil swelling and shrinking with the seasons. Signs to watch include sticking doors, cracks over openings and stair-step cracks in brick. Basements and retaining walls add their own drainage questions. Fort Worth requires a building permit and engineered plans for residential foundation repair, and foundation work is on the city's COA list.
Storms that hit close
NOAA's Storm Events Database has several reports within a mile or so:
- May 23 and 24, 2011: ping pong to golf ball size hail at the Fort Worth Zoo, then baseball size (2.75 inch) hail the next evening, plotted by NOAA less than half a mile from the neighborhood.
- March 17, 2016: hail up to 2.5 inches at the Fort Worth Zoo. NOAA estimated the storm caused about $600 million in damage in Tarrant County.
- October 24, 2025: gusts estimated near 61 mph blew trees over on the Medical City Fort Worth campus, just north of the neighborhood.
How we work in historic neighborhoods
Before we price a roof in a district like Mistletoe Heights, we note what the roof is made of today and photograph each slope, the chimney and the vents. If the material stays the same, the estimate says so. If you are weighing a change, we can lay out repair and replacement options in writing for your COA application. The city decides, and work should wait for its answer.
Common questions
Can I switch my Mistletoe Heights tile roof to shingles?
Not without review. The district guidelines say any change in roofing material, with tile to composition given as the example, shall be reviewed by the Historic and Cultural Landmarks Commission. Replacing composition with composition is the like-for-like case.
Where can turbines and attic fans go on a Mistletoe Heights roof?
The guidelines allow attic ventilation, but attic fans or turbines must sit on a side or rear roof, away from the main facade of the house.
Do I need to talk to the city if my re-roof does not need a permit?
Yes, check first. The Mistletoe Heights guidelines tell owners to contact the Historic Preservation Officer during planning whether or not a building permit is needed, to find out if a Certificate of Appropriateness is required. Today the city's contact is [email protected] or 817-392-8000.
How long does a Landmarks Commission review take?
The commission meets the second Monday of each month at 2 p.m., and the application deadline is the third Monday of the month before. So a commission case takes about three weeks or more from the deadline to the hearing. Staff-level approvals have no published time frame.
Why do foundations act differently across Mistletoe Heights?
USDA soil maps show shallow, stony Aledo and Bolar soils on the sloped bluff ground and moderately deep Mingo clay loam in a flatter part of the neighborhood. USDA says Mingo cracks when dry. Shallow soil over limestone and deeper clay can move very differently under a house.
Sources
- City of Fort Worth, Historic Preservation (COA list, Accela application, HCLC schedule, contact)
- City of Fort Worth, Historic Districts (Mistletoe Heights, designated 2002)
- Mistletoe Heights Historic and Cultural District Guidelines (City of Fort Worth)
- Fort Worth Magazine, River Dwellers: Fort Worth's Trinity River Neighborhood Guide (Feb. 16, 2016)
- Historic Fort Worth, Agee-Renfro-Vandervoort House, Mistletoe Heights
- National Park Service, Preservation Brief 30: The Preservation and Repair of Historic Clay Tile Roofs
- City of Fort Worth, Residential Re-Roofing FAQ (PDF)
- USDA NRCS Soil Data Access (map units 372375 Aledo-Bolar-Urban land and 372396 Mingo-Urban land, queried at points in the neighborhood)
- USDA NRCS Official Soil Series Description: Aledo
- USDA NRCS Official Soil Series Description: Mingo
- NOAA NCEI Storm Events Database, event 306785: 2.75 inch hail, Fort Worth, 24 May 2011
- NOAA NCEI Storm Events Database, event 625920: 2.50 inch hail at the Fort Worth Zoo, 17 Mar 2016
- NOAA NCEI Storm Events Database, event 1298363: thunderstorm wind, Medical City Fort Worth campus, 24 Oct 2025
Have a leak, storm damage or a project in mind?
Free inspections and written estimates, with photos of what we find.
